Document
ESMP Valea Lupului
Fișierul original pe site-ul primăriei
PDF · 2,3 MB · modificat pe site: 14.09.2023
Pagina sursă
Cum citez acest document
Document, „ESMP Valea Lupului”, Comuna Valea Lupului, jud. Iași. Sursa: http://comuna-valealupului.ro/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/ESMP_Valea-Lupului-3.pdf (arhivat pe acte-primarii.ro: https://acte-primarii.ro/iasi/valea-lupului/4256-esmp-valea-lupului, 04.11.2026)
Textul afișat a fost obținut prin recunoaștere automată (OCR) și poate conține greșeli. Documentul oficial este fișierul publicat de primărie.
Semnalează o problemă (text greșit, date personale, document scos de primărie)
Pagina 1
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
“Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable Schools” Project
ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL MANAGEMENT PLAN
„ Mihai Dumitriu” Secondary School - Valea Lupului
Demolition and reconstruction
AUGUST 2023
Pagina 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABREVIATIONS 3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4
1. GENERAL PROJECT AND ESMP INFORMATION 7
1.1 Project overview 7
1.2 Scope and objectives the ESMP 8
2. DESCRIPTION OF VALEA LUPULUI SECONDARY SCHOOL SUBPROJECT 10
2.1 Description of area and community affected by the investment 10
2.2 Valea Lupului Secondary School 10
2.3. Location and characteristics of the site for investment 11
2.4 Proposed design for new school building 13
2.5 Associated Facilities 18
2.6 Temporary School Relocation Solution 19
2.7 Description of demolition and construction works expected 20
2.8 Temporary facilities required during the demolition and construction phase 21
3. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES 22
3.1 Key social risks and impacts 22
3.2 Social Impact Screening Process 22
3.3 Key environmental risks and impacts 25
3.4 Environmental and Social Management Plan 28
4. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS 36
5. THE PLAN FOR MONITORING SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS 40
6. STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE 46
7. INVOLVEMENT OF INTERESTED PARTIES 50
8. GRIEVANCES MECHANISM 52
ANNEX 1 - REQUIREMENTS AND MEASURES WHEN HANDLING ASBESTOS 54
ANNEX 2 - PROCEDURE FOR MANAGEMENT OF PHYSICAL CULTURAL RESOURCES –
PROTECTION AND CHANCE FIND PROCEDURES 55
ANNEX 3 - FORM FOR SUBMITTING SUGGESTIONS / COMMENTS 56
2|Page
Pagina 3
ABREVIATIONS
ACM Asbestos Containing Materials
CCEAR County Center for Educational Assistance and Resources
CSI County School Inspectorate
E&S Environmental and Social
EA Environmental Assessment
EC European Commission
EGO Emergency Governmental Ordinance
EIA Environmental Impact Assessment
EP Environmental Permit
EMP Environmental Management Plan
ESF Environmental and Social Framework
ESIA Environmental Social Impact Assessment
ESMF Environmental Social Management Framework
ESMP Environmental Social Management Plan
ESS Environmental and Social Standards
EU European Union
GBV Gender Based Violence
GD Governmental Decision
GO Governmental Ordinance
GRS Grievance Redress Service
LMP Labor Management Plan
MoE Ministry of Education
MEWF Ministry for the Environment, Water and Forests
MoC Ministry of Culture
OJR Official Journal of Romania
OP Operational Policy
SISSP Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable Schools Project
PMU Project Management Unit
Project Management Unit for the Modernization of the
PMUMSUN
School and University Network
POM Project Operation Manual
SEP Stakeholder Engagement Plan
TOR Terms of reference
WMP Waste Management Plans
WB World Bank
3|Page
Pagina 4
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Introduction. The Secondary School” Mihai Dumitriu” Valea Lupului has been selected under the „Safer,
Sustainable and Inclusive Schools Project” (SSISP) and will benefit from investments intended to
increase the quality and safety of the educational infrastructure. The Project aims to provide safer and
improved learning environments for students and teachers in selected schools, and to increase
institutional capacity for investing in sustainable education infrastructure.
The Project has been approved in 2021 and is implemented, over a period of six years, by the Ministry of
Education with financial support from the World Bank. It will address challenges related to issues of
safety, inclusion and sustainability in the school infrastructure in Romania. The five components under
the Project are: i) Demonstrating Integrated Investments in School Infrastructure, ii) Investing in Clever
Classrooms; iii) Foundations for Future Investments in Sustainable and Modern Schools Infrastructure;
iv) Project Management; and v) Contingent Emergency Response Component. More information about
the project can be found at https://umpmrsu.ro/sissp/descriere/.
Valea Lupului Subproject description
The building of the Valea Lupului Secondary School was built in 1974 and initially included 9 classrooms
and one laboratory. In 1992 an adjoint building with 4 additional classrooms was finalized. Because the
spaces available do not cover the needs generated by the growing number of students enrolled, 2 more
classrooms are operating in temporary units made out of containers, located in the school yard.
The technical survey revealed a SR II Seismic Risk for the Building of the school meaning that there is a
high risk of major structural damage in the event of an earthquake. The building will be demolished
together with an annex currently used as a deposit and a new school will be erected to host 22 classrooms,
laboratories and modern facilities for the students. During construction, pupils will be relocated to a
modular school that will be located on a land plot provided by the local authority.
The proposed new building will have a built area of 1295 sqm and a developed area of 4606 sqm and will
have a capacity to host up 572 student under one shift (out of the 641 of the children currently enrolled
in primary and secondary education. The school will be aligned with the latest seismic standards, near
zero energy building standard, universal access for all children, adapted bathrooms for the needs of
teenage girls, a cafeteria for lunch breaks and school events, among other functions. The investment for
the new school, including equipment and furniture, will be covered entirely by Project funding, while
some associated investments will be covered by the local authority, such as preparing the land that will
host the temporary school and connecting it to the utilities, demolition of the old school on the area
planned for the new construction, playground area, landscaping, courtyard lighting, alleys, utility
connections, parking lots. These associated facilities will be performed in parallel with the school
construction and will be clearly defined under a Protocol between the Project Management Unit for the
Modernization of the School and University Network (PMUMSUN, abbreviated in text as PMU) and Valea
Lupului local authority.
Environmental and Social Framework. The Project is financed by the World Bank and it is guided by
the Environmental and Social Framework of the institution (document available on the project website
at https://umpmrsu.ro/sissp/documente-cadru/), which supports green, resilient and inclusive
development by strengthening protections for people and the environment and making important
advances in areas such as labor, inclusion and non-discrimination, gender equity, climate change,
biodiversity, community health and safety, and stakeholder engagement. In addition to the design of the
new schools which will incorporate these elements, the Project aims at ensuring the protection of the
environment and the community during and after the school is being rebuilt. For this purpose, a series of
4|Page
Pagina 5
documents, frameworks and plans have been developed at the level of the Project in order to ensure the
safety of children, community members, workers, identify and mitigate adverse impacts during works,
and engage the local community in the process (Environmental and Social Management Framework,
Stakeholder Engagement Plan, Labor Management Plan, etc.). All these documents can be consulted on
the Project’s website https://umpmrsu.ro/sissp/.
Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP)
The ESMP outlines the main environmental and social risks associated with the investment in Valea
Lupului. The overall findings of the ESMP indicate short-term negative impacts on air, soil, water, and
acoustic environment during civil works. The environmental issues likely to be associated with the
project activities include: noise generation, impact on soil and on water by the construction run-offs,
construction dust and wastes, and workers’ safety. However, these adverse impacts will be temporary
and site specific and will be mitigated through implementing adequate avoidance and/or mitigation
measures such as appropriate fencing, appropriate management of construction waste, H&S monitoring,
development of clear procedures on site, site-specific organization of the works.
The project is expected to have a mainly positive social impact at the level of the community by providing
a healthy and safe environment for future students and school staff members reducing the risks of
collapse and human accidents in case of an earthquake, contributing to the climate change adaptation
process, providing gender equity and universal access in the newly built facilities. In relation to potential
social risks, the ESMP addresses the children and community health and safety risks, including the risk
of accidents, disturbances to the educational activity and for neighboring residents, gender-based
violence risks, awareness in relation to disaster risks, exclusion of vulnerable groups from the benefits of
the investment, etc.
For this purpose, the ESMP proposes a set of mitigation measures and relies on community outreach and
consultations with those directly impacted (school staff, children, parents) and the community at large
to manage these risks across the different phases of the Project. A dedicated grievance mechanism will
assist the community to reach the Project in relation to any issues observed during Project
implementation.
A monitoring plan attached to the ESMP will be the basis for constantly checking compliance with the
proposed risk mitigation measures.
Institutional Responsibilities
The overall responsibility for implementing the provisions of the current ESMP lies with the PMU
dedicated for this project. The Valea Lupului local authority will also need to ensure compliance with the
provisions of the ESMP in relation to the works carried with local funding. All other actors involved in the
process, such as contractors, the Valea Lupului Secondary School representatives, will be informed about
their responsibilities and bidding documents, contracts and protocols will define roles, timelines and
actions expected from each stakeholder. The ESMF developed by the Project includes guidelines and
instructions for contractors to integrate in their own environmental and social management plans,
requested under their contracts.
Consultations and stakeholder engagement. Community and individual consultations began early in
the project planning phase, aimed at collecting initial views on the school design and allow for changes
as needed. These consultations are guided by the Stakeholder Engagement Plan developed for the Project,
accessible on the Project’s website.
5|Page
Pagina 6
With the design contract signed in March 2023, a first round of consultations was held in Valea Lupului
with representatives of local authorities, schools, teachers and representatives of students and parents,
during which general information about the project, the site plan and the proposed design for the new
construction in terms of spaces and functions, and the facilities proposed to make the building safer,
sustainable and inclusive were presented. Questions and suggestions from the participants were
recorded and a new consultation on the final design will be held in August 2023.
In relation to the current ESMP, this document will be disclosed and consulted with the community
during the August 2023 consultation. The public consultations, as well as individual consultations where
needed, enable stakeholders to provide input that will help the implementation team to anticipate the
impacts of the project more accurately and design more appropriate and effective measures to manage
the risks generated. The consultation will be announced in advance at the level of the community and the
grievance mechanism will ensure communication channels before and after the consultations. A
community event disclosing the proposed design, as well as the provisions under the current ESMP will
be organized by the school and local authority, with support from the Project during the disclosure of the
current ESMP in August 2023.
All Project materials, information and documents can be found at www.umpmrsu.ro.
Grievance Redress Mechanism. The GRM provides the community members and a range of other
stakeholders with the possibility to communicate their views, complaints, suggestions in relation to the
Project. This will give the possibility to mitigate any adverse environmental and social risks that the
project may encounter in its implementation as well as to give the community a permanent
communication channel with the Project.
The main four channels for receiving grievances are by website form on www.umpmrsu.ro , phone – (+4)
021 310 22 07, email – [email protected] and mail at the level of the PMU, Str. Spiru Haret, nr. 12,
Sector 1, București. This ensures that the PMU has an immediate control over all project related
grievances and can address the raised issues immediately.
The Project developed a Gender-based Violence Action Plan (part of the Stakeholder Engagement Plan)
in order to protect the community and staff from any cases of sexual harassment and exploitation. A
separate safe and confidential reporting channel for the incidence of gender-based violence is available
by e-mail address at [email protected] , or in person, by contacting the Project and requesting a
meeting with the social specialist on the team.
6|Page
Pagina 7
1. GENERAL PROJECT AND ESMP INFORMATION
1.1 Project overview
Context of the Project
The proposed “Romania Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable Schools” Project addresses development
challenges related to issues of safety, inclusion and sustainability in the school infrastructure in Romania.
The Project has been approved in 2021 and is implemented, over a period of six years, by the Ministry of
Education with financial support from the World Bank1 .
There is an urgent need to invest in quality and safe school infrastructure in Romania, with a high
proportion of school buildings failing to meet basic sanitary and safety standards and which pose a
substantial risk to lives in a future earthquake, a future pandemic and as the climate warms.
The Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable Schools Project (SISSP) aims to provide safer and improved learning
environments for students and teachers in selected schools, and to increase institutional capacity for
investing in sustainable education infrastructure. The investments in the participating schools will serve
as a demonstration of the preparation and implementation process of works to modernize and improve
school infrastructure. The Project is expected to lay the foundations for future investments through State
and European Union (EU) funds in school infrastructure. Valea Lupului Secondary School has been
selected to be part of the first batch of investments, together with other 21 schools in the country. The
technical design phase for Valea Lupului Secondary School has commenced in February 2023 and the
construction works are estimated to begin starting with 2024. The main criteria for school selection were
the results of seismic risk assessments, together with school marginality data. A list of all selection criteria
and methodology can be found on the Project’s website.
Objectives
The SISSP Project aims to develop safer and better educational environments for students and teachers
in selected schools and to strengthen institutional capacity to invest in sustainable school infrastructure.
Components
The five components under the Project are: i) Demonstrating Integrated Investments in School
Infrastructure, ii) Investing in Clever Classrooms; iii) Foundations for Future Investments in Sustainable
and Modern Schools Infrastructure; iv) Project Management; and v) Contingent Emergency Response
Component.
The project will include:
i. Execution of construction works at selected educational units, in order to create a modern
infrastructure, resistant to earthquakes and other natural disasters and to increase operational safety;
ii. The endowment with modern and flexible furniture, the endowment with digital
equipment of the classrooms in order to improve the quality of the educational process, the
endowment with educational materials that will allow the stimulation of the learning capacity;
1 The Board of the WB approved on 29th of April 2021 a Loan on the amount of 100 million euros (EUR)
(equivalent to USD 121,07 million) to Romania for the implementation of the SISS Project. The Loan Agreement
Number 9236-RO was signed between the WB and the Government of Romania, represented by MoF, on 6th of May
2021 and it is in the process of ratification. The SISS Project is to be implemented over a period of six years, between
2021 and 2027.
7|Page
Pagina 8
iii. Teacher training to improve digital skills and understanding modern alternative methods that
will encourage active student participation, group work/social learning and will be sensitive to students'
individual motivations and differences;
iv. Providing institutional support to local authorities for accessing European funds that will be
available in the financial year 2021-2027 in order to make investments in modernization of school
infrastructure;
v. Training of students, teachers and community awareness by promoting actions that can be taken
to build disaster resilience and climate change, disaster preparedness and response, opportunities to
increase sustainability (such as zero waste, water harvesting, energy use and conservation, etc.).
1.2 Scope and objectives the ESMP
The Project is supported by the World Bank through an Investment Project Financing Instrument. As a
consequence, the Borrower is required to identify and assess the environmental and social risks
associated with the Project and to propose an integrated management of these risks throughout the
preparation and implementation phases. This process is carried under the World Bank Environmental
and Social Framework (ESF) that enables the WB and Borrowers to better manage environmental and
social risks of projects and to improve development outcomes.
The Bank believes that the application of these standards, by focusing on the identification and
management of environmental and social risks, will support Borrowers in their goal to reduce poverty
and increase prosperity in a sustainable manner for the benefit of the environment and their citizens. The
standards will: (a) support Borrowers in achieving good international practice relating to environmental
and social sustainability; (b) assist Borrowers in fulfilling their national and international environmental
and social obligations; (c) enhance nondiscrimination, transparency, participation, accountability and
governance; and (d) enhance the sustainable development outcomes of projects through ongoing
stakeholder engagement.
The objective of the current ESMP, developed in the specific context of the "Mihai Dumitriu" Secondary
School Valea Lupului sub-project is to ensure that the social and environmental impacts that may occur
in the implementation of the Valea Lupului Secondary School ”Mihai Dumitriu” sub-project activities are
adequately addressed through appropriate mitigation measures, integrated in the processes of
implementation and operation of the sub-project, in order to ensure the protection of the environment
and human health. This objective is in line with the Environmental and Social Management Framework,
a document that was prepared by the Project in 2020, at project design level and which incorporates all
the requirements that are applicable to the project, as well as main risks and mitigation measures to be
implemented across all investments (document available on the project website).
The development of the current ESMP is based on the provisions of World Bank’s Environmental and
Social Framework (ESF) that requires Borrowers to assess and manage environmental and social risks of
projects supported by the WB. The ESF is built upon the 10 WB’s Environmental and Social Standards
(ESS), out which, the following six apply to the SISSP and establish the standards that the Borrower and
the project will meet through the project life cycle, as follows:
ESS1: Assessment and Management of ESS Risks and Impacts;
ESS2: Labor and Working Conditions
ESS3: Resource Efficiency and Pollution Prevention;
ESS4: Community Health and Safety;
ESS8: Cultural Heritage This ESS8; even though not applicable to subproject the
standard is relevant to “Chance find procedure” in the ESMF as the civil work activities
are likely to have risks and impacts on cultural heritage.
ESS10: Information Disclosure and Stakeholder Engagement;
8|Page
Pagina 9
The ESSs that apply to the project have been analyzed and adapted to the context in Romania and a series
of tools and documents have been elaborated in the Project Preparation phase in 2020. These
instruments include the Environmental and Social Management Framework, Stakeholder Engagement
Plan, Labor Management Plan, Grievance Redress Procedure, Gender Based Violence Action Plan, etc. In
addition, two studies carried by the World Bank in the context of the Project, assessing the specific needs
and concerns of different vulnerable categories that might be impacted by the investments in schools,
have informed the Project design. All these documents can be consulted on the Project’s website.
The Environmental and Social Management Framework also contains a review of applicable Romanian
legislation, in addition to an in-depth presentation of the World Bank’s standards. The framework
document can be consulted on the Project website.
9|Page
Pagina 10
2. DESCRIPTION OF VALEA LUPULUI SECONDARY SCHOOL SUBPROJECT
2.1 Description of area and community affected by the investment
Valea Lupului is a commune located on the western border of Iasi Municipality in the metropolitan area
of the city and consists of only one settlement, Valea Lupului, covering a 10 sq kms area.
The commune was established in 2004 when it was separated from Rediu commune, joined Beldiman
village and became Valea Lupului locality, with commune (administrative unit) status. In the last years,
the locality has experienced a marked demographic development mainly due to the proximity of the
Municipality of Iași.
According to the last census in 2021 the total population is of 14510 inhabitants, almost triple compared
to the previous census in 2011 when 4982 inhabitants were registered 2. The data provided by the local
population registration services indicate figures below 11500, which could be due to the fact that people
move to Valea Lupului from Iași and delay changing their identity card, probably in order to keep some
opportunities associated with the status of being a resident of the municipality.
During the last decade the number of children aged 6 to 14 has also increased two and a half times 3.
2.2 Valea Lupului Secondary School
Valea Lupului Secondary School was selected in the first batch of 22 schools that will be the object of
investments within the project. The school was considered eligible because it is located in an area with
seismic risk and it’s at high risk of suffering major structural damage in case of earthquake (according to
the technical expertise, the building falls into the category of seismic risk class SR II); also, the
demographic dynamics are showing a high growth of the population in the past decade.
Valea Lupului Secondary School is the only legal entity in the locality and currently provides educational
services for 641 pupils, of which 469 are enrolled in 21 primary classes and 172 in 8 secondary classes.
The School operates two buildings located in different places in the administrative unit, distributed as
follow:
- the building included in the project, with 14 classrooms situated on 13 Nucilor Street,
- a recently built facility with 7 classrooms located on 1 Perla Street that is used by the secondary classes
starting with the beginning of 2023.
The school also runs 17 kindergarten classes with 386 children.
Currently, the main building of the school is operated in two shifts because it does not provide enough
classrooms for all the students to learn under one shift.
The number of children enrolled at the local school is in the current school year more than double
compared to ten years ago. A sharper increase in the number of children enrolled has occurred in the last
5 years. The growing trend of the number of students is maintained for the next year and it is very likely
to continue considering the large number of children enrolled in the kindergarten that is part of the
structure of the secondary school in Valea Lupului. A statistical analysis of official data available on the
website of the National Institute of Statistics4 and on the school`s website 5 showed that in the last 5 years
the percent of parents choosing to enroll their children in Valea Lupului Secondary School has increased
from 32% to 44%.
2 https://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valea_Lupului,_Ia%C8%99i accessed on 10 april 2023
3 http://statistici.insse.ro:8077/tempo-online/#/pages/tables/insse-table accessed on 10 april 2023
4 http://statistici.insse.ro:8077/tempo-online/#/pages/tables/insse-table accessed on 10 april 2023
5 https://scoalavalealupului.ro/plan-de-dezvoltare-institutionala/ accessed on 10 april 2023
10 | P a g e
Pagina 11
A projection made by the school on the evolution of the number of classes and pupils enrolled shows that
in four years the school will have 21 secondary classes and 40 primary classes. The analysis takes into
account both the current number of pupils and classes in the Valea Lupului school and the number of
children enrolled in kindergarten and the enrolment rate of children in the local school.
According to a recent decision of the MoE the school has a provisional authorization to include high school
studies and in the schooling plan for the year 2023-2024 a high school class with 26 students has been
included.
Description of the current building proposed for demolition and reconstruction:
The building of the school included in the project is located on the public domain on the land plot of Valea
Lupului Secondary School, along a sports field and a sports hall. The building has been finalized in 1974
(originally included 9 classrooms and one laboratory) and extended in 1992 with 4 additional
classrooms. Because the spaces available do not cover the needs generated by the growing number of
students enrolled, with the help of the local authority, 2 more classrooms were set up in a temporary
building made of containers, located in the school yard.
The current building of the school has a footprint of 755,38 square meters and a floor area of 1465,61
square meters with a ground floor and first floor. The school building has been technically assessed and
has been classified in seismic risk class SR II.
Considering the age of the building, its technical condition and the extremely high costs of the
interventions for the consolidation and extension of the educational premises to meet the requirements
of the school unit, the technical expertise proposed the demolition of the building.
The building is connected to the electricity, water and sewage network and it is heated by a gas-fired
central heating system.
Currently the building does not provide facilities for universal access.
2.3. Location and characteristics of the site for investment
The results of the technical survey revealed the need to demolish the existing building and construct the
new on the same land plot.
The site of the investment consists of a land plot of 5319 sqm that is registered as a public land of the
local authority, located on the 13 Nucilor street. The description below details some of the main
characteristics of the proposed site for construction:
The proposed land currently hosts the building of the Secondary School in Valea Lupului, a sports field
and a sports hall, both used by the students of the school.
11 | P a g e
Pagina 12
Fig. 1 The school positioning in the neighborhood
In terms of vicinities, the land is bordered by local roads – Nucilor, Zmeurei and Unirii streets, a private
property and the building of the kindergarten within the school`s legal structure. The area is residential
and is characterized mostly by private unifamilial houses.
During the pick-up or drop-off of the children from the school the traffic on the adjacent streets gets very
congested. To reduce the risk of traffic jams, the local authority has imposed one-way traffic on
neighboring streets.
The land does not include historical buildings and it is not located in the protection area of a historical
monument.
In order to make way for the new construction, both the building of the school and the annex currently
used as a deposit located on the site will be demolished, according to the sketch below.
Also, the temporary modular building that currently houses 2 classrooms, located in the schoolyard, will
be dismantled.
Fig. 2 The building proposed for demolition. The location of the modular building is marked in light blue.
12 | P a g e
Pagina 13
The figure above indicates the constructions on site, with C1(marked blue), the building subject to the
investment, as well as an annex proposed for demolition to make way for the new construction.
2.4 Proposed design for new school building
The new school project aims to integrate and bring to life the latest best practice in contemporary school
design:
▪ Integration of technology
▪ Safety and security
▪ Transparency
▪ Multi-purpose space
▪ Outdoor learning
The basic principle of the project is the safe and efficient operation of the spaces, based on sustainability
principles. The designed systems aim at producing energy from renewable sources, limiting
consumption, environmental control and ease of maintenance, reducing operating and maintenance
costs, protecting the environment and increasing operational safety, with the main objective of
implementing the NZEB concept as efficiently as possible.
Fig. 3 Designer renderings of the interior of the new building
13 | P a g e
Pagina 14
The proposed new building will have a built area of 1295 sqm and a developed area of 4606 sqm and will
be able to host up to 572 children under one shift. The school will be aligned with the latest seismic
standards, near zero energy building standard, universal access for all children, adapted bathrooms for
the needs of teenage girls, a cafeteria for lunch breaks and school events.
Fig. 4 Proposed positioning of the new building
The spatial-functional organization of the proposed building includes the following spaces:
▪ 22 classrooms;
▪ 3 laboratories (out of which one for computer science, one for chemistry, both equipped with
storage space);
▪ dedicated area for documentation, research, and information activities;
▪ library;
▪ cafeteria designed to simultaneously serve meals in three shifts, equipped with a
handwashing/disinfection area, a counter area for serving meals, a storage area and an office
space;
▪ administrative area for teachers, consisting of a school office, a secretary's office, a principal's
office, and a staff room;
▪ medical office for consultations and treatments, including an isolation room;
▪ psychological counseling office with a special room for calming children who may be experiencing
emotional distress, designed to help students manage their emotions, reduce stress, and regain
self-control;
▪ storage spaces for cleaning materials and technical areas dedicated to equipment ensuring the
lighting, heating, cooling, and ventilation of the building, as well as those with fire protection
purposes.
Below are the designer proposed plans for the new school building:
14 | P a g e
Pagina 15
Semi-basement
15 | P a g e
Pagina 16
Ground Floor
16 | P a g e
Pagina 17
First Floor
17 | P a g e
Pagina 18
Second Floor
Fig. 5 Proposed plans for the new construction
2.5 Associated Facilities
Given the limited resources at the level of the Project and the priority to increase the seismic safety of
children in schools at risk across the country, some of the associated elements of the investments will be
funded and implemented by local authorities, considering budgetary availability at local level. From an
18 | P a g e
Pagina 19
environmental and social perspective, these associated investments will be approached as Associated
Facilities of the Investment.
Associated Facilities means facilities or activities that are not funded as part of the Project and, in the
judgment of the World Bank, are: (a) directly and significantly related to the project; and (b) carried out,
or planned to be carried out, contemporaneously with the project; and (c) necessary for the project to be
viable and would not have been constructed, expanded or conducted if the project did not exist.
The E&S standards of the Project, defined under the current ESMP, will apply to these Associated
Facilities. In practice, the requirements under the current ESMP will apply to all Contractors, irrespective
of the contracted works (demolitions, constructions, landscaping, etc.). The PMU will assist the local
authority in implementing and monitoring the measures set out in the current ESMP for the associated
facilities.
Description of interventions expected to be carried by the local authorities:
▪ Demolition of the old school building and the annex currently standing on the land on which the
new building will be erected;
▪ Preparation of mobile classroom site and utility connections;
▪ Playground area next to the school;
▪ Alleys, courtyard lighting, exterior furniture and landscaping;
▪ Parking lots;
▪ Utility connections for the proposed new building.
2.6 Temporary School Relocation Solution
The subproject will need a mobile classroom solution to accommodate the educational and
extracurricular activities during the demolition and construction works. For the school year 2023-2024
the school will have 36 classes and only 7 classrooms available.
The mobile classroom will include several containers arranged in a fluid manner to accommodate the
functions of the educational activities. It will provide similar functions as a standard building, with
separate toilets for girls and boys, classrooms, heating units, lighting, standard furniture. The site will
need to be prepared in advance by the local authority and will include the connection to electricity, water
and wastewater. Heating will be ensured by electrical heaters.
The solution will be consulted with the school representatives, local authority and school community
(parents, teachers, children). The costs associated with the mobile classrooms will be under the
responsibility of the Project, while the preparation of the site and utility connection will fall under the
responsibility of the local authority in Valea Lupului.
19 | P a g e
Pagina 20
Fig. 6 Examples of modular classrooms in Bucharest and Constanța
2.7 Description of demolition and construction works expected
The demolition will be contracted by the local authority. The works are expected to take two months and
will be carried under strict guidance outlined in the technical design documentation associated with the
demolition process, prepared under the responsibility of the local authority in Valea Lupului. The process
will involve the disconnection of the current buildings from utilities, the set-up of the construction site
within the premises (offices, toilets, changing rooms for staff) and temporary connection to utilities, the
fencing and restrictions of accessing the site, equipping the site with health and safety equipment,
providing training to workers on site, set-up of environmental protection measures (vehicles washing,
transport of debris, protection of green spaces on the construction site).
The technological process of demolition will involve the use of vehicles and machinery specific to
construction works such as bulldozers, excavators, jackhammers and dump trucks. The trucks that will
go in and out of the site will undergo a wheel washing process and will be covered to avoid the overspill
of debris on public roads. A project information board and a grievance system board and letter box will
assure that both community members and site workers will be able to communicate any grievances and
suggestions to the project team, in relation to the demolition process.
The construction of the new building will most probably last between 12 and 18 months. The first period
will be allocated to the site preparation for the construction of the new building and the installation of
the necessary equipment for the construction works (site organization).
The new building will have a built area of 1295 sqm and a developed area of 4606 sqm. The infrastructure
of the building is made of insulated foundations under the superstructure columns and reinforced
concrete beams. A general excavation will be carried out on the whole surface of the building for the
foundations. A layer of sand and gravel is placed under the slab above ground level to break the
capillarity. Thermal insulation of the above ground slab will be made with 20 cm thick extruded
polystyrene. Horizontal waterproofing will be provided under the ground floor walls to prevent damp.
The superstructure of the building consists of reinforced concrete frames composed of columns, beams
and reinforced concrete slabs. Access to the first floor will be via two reinforced concrete staircases.
The roof will be of non-circulating terrace type, with heat-sealing membrane. On the main access area, an
awning will be built by removing the cantilever slab over the floor, with reinforced concrete structure,
continuing the non-circulating terrace roofing.
20 | P a g e
Pagina 21
The external enclosures will be made of 30 cm thick BCA masonry, thermally insulated with a ventilated
facade system with a 15 cm thick basalt plaster thermos-system. The interior partitions will be made of
30 cm thick BCA masonry for the teaching areas and 15 cm thick for the other areas. The exterior joinery
will be aluminum, glazed, low-e, 4s, with a minimum corrected resistance of 0.83 m2K/W and the curtain
wall in the main entrance area will be double-glazed, low-e, 4s, with a minimum corrected resistance of
0.77 m2K/W. The interior joinery will be aluminum, with full panel and glass panel. The interior floors
will be made with PVC carpet. In wet areas (sanitary), non-slip ceramic tiles will be used. Walls and
ceilings will be plastered, sanded and painted with super washable paint. The ceilings will be made of
plasterboard with 60x120 cm sound-absorbing panels.
2.8 Temporary facilities required during the demolition and construction phase
Demolition and construction activities will require temporary installations on site. The installation of
these facilities will allow the performance of various functions of the site, including the storage of building
materials, waste management, the arrangement of offices, dedicated spaces for workers and the
provision of health and safety on the site.
All the temporary facilities will be installed inside the land plot of the school. The construction site will
be installed on the ground and will include the placement of modular containers to serve as offices,
changing rooms for site workers and as a warehouse for equipment. Ecological toilets will be installed on
the site, and their contents will be constantly emptied by the supplier. Separated toilets for women will
be installed, if necessary. A truck washing platform will be provided to clean the wheels of trucks leaving
the site during demolition and construction work.
At the entrance to the site, a panel dedicated to the mechanism for receiving petitions/complaints with a
related mailbox will be installed. Construction workers will be informed about the possibility of
contacting the management unit or of submitting an anonymous complaint about the working conditions
and the health and safety provisions on the spot, in addition to the grievance mechanism that is expected
to function at the level of the Contractors.
The temporary facilities required during the construction works will take into account the designation of
spaces for the storage of materials, washing and decontamination facilities for vehicles, contamination
control points, ecological toilets, wastewater treatment services, offices and night lighting. Special
attention will be given to the security of the site. Appropriate fencing and controlled access to the site will
be ensured and the works related traffic will be organized in a manner that will not put at risk the
activities and persons in the vicinity (activities in the near-by kindergarten, children playing in the school
playground, neighbors, passers-by). The noise and dust levels will be constantly monitored and
appropriate measures will be taken to keep them under the legally admitted maximum. All these
measures will be captured in the Project detailed design documentation, the bidding documents and the
contracts signed with designated construction companies.
21 | P a g e
Pagina 22
3. ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES
3.1 Key social risks and impacts
The project is expected to have a considerable positive impact at the level of the Valea Lupului
community, children and teachers. This project aims that teachers and students have access to schools
that are safe from earthquake, fire and other disaster and climate risks, meet minimum standards for
sanitation, heating, ventilation, are energy efficient, can safely resume during health pandemics, such as
Covid-19, and provide universal access to students with disabilities.
By providing a comprehensive solution, through a single investment, the community can reduce dropout
or early school leaving, increase educational outcomes and provide safe learning environments.
Strengthening disaster resilience and emergency infrastructure in severely damaged buildings at the
level of selected units across Romania, will increase the chances of communities to be safely assisted in
the event of disasters and will also provide improved and standardized working conditions for the
employees and users of these facilities.
In relation to the WB’s ESF, the social development and inclusion under the Project aims at empowering
all people to participate in, and benefit from, the development process. Inclusion encompasses policies
to promote equality and nondiscrimination by improving the access of all people, including the poor and
disadvantaged, to the educational services that will result from the investment. It also embraces action
to remove barriers against those who are often excluded from the development process, such as women,
children, persons with disabilities, youth and minorities, and to ensure that the voice of all can be heard.
3.2 Social Impact Screening Process
Regarding the vulnerable categories that might be impacted by the Project, two research studies carried
by the World Bank in 2020 in the context of the Project preparation, namely, a Community Vulnerability
Assessment and a Roma Children Learning Experiences Assessment revealed several aspects that
contribute to the objectives of the planned investments. The two studies carried interviews with children
and parents coming from vulnerable and marginalized communities, and concluded several interventions
that can be addressed by the project in order to improve the experience of vulnerable children in the
newly built schools (e.g. adding cafeterias for hot meal programs, adapting to the needs of children with
disabilities, addressing the lack of access to modern technologies for children from poor environments,
etc.).
An environmental and social checklist was developed at project design stage, including elements related
to the social and environmental context of the investments. Several site visits and consultations with
relevant stakeholders have also informed the social risk assessment related to the Valea Lupului subproject. The specific aspects that informed the risk analysis are:
▪ No land acquisition is involved in the process, as all works will be carried on the same public land
that hosts the present building and that is in the property of the local authority in Valea Lupului
(both the land under the existing school and the land that will serve as the site for the future
construction are owned by the Valea Lupului Local Council);
▪ The land plot where the school will be erected also hosts a sports field and a sports hall currently
used by the school`s students;
▪ The site is bordered by local roads, a kindergarten within the school`s structure and residential
units. Adapted measures need to be implemented in order to reduce the disturbance and the
safety risks generated by the construction works;
▪ Traffic on adjacent streets is very busy when children are dropped off or picked up from school.
One-way traffic management on the streets in the vicinity of the school was recently implemented
to improve the situation;
22 | P a g e
Pagina 23
▪ During the demolition and construction works children will be relocated in a modular school
financed by the project, that will be placed on a land provided by the local authority;
▪ The current building is not a cultural heritage building and is not located in the protection area of
a historical monument;
▪ In the past decade the population of the village has tripled, from 4982 in 2011 to 14510 according
to provisional data of 2021 census. Also, the number of school-aged children has increased 2.5
times in the past decade;
▪ A sharp increase of the number of students enrolled in Valea Lupului Secondary School occurred
in the past 5 years; the trend persists for the next year and it is very likely to continue considering
the large number of children enrolled in the kindergarten. Also, the percent of parents choosing
to enroll their kids to the local school have increased from 32% to 44%;
▪ Based on existing data on the number of children enrolled in kindergarten and school and the
enrolment rate, it is estimated that in four years the school will have 21 secondary classes and 40
primary classes.
Social risks identified under Project Activities:
The social risks identified at this stage are based on data collected at the level of Valea Lupului, through
checklists, observational site visits, consultations, and similar civil works projects. Some of the risks of
exclusion that were identified in Project preparation, back in 2020, were already addressed in specific
design requirements, such as the inclusion of cafeteria in all schools under the project, dedicated facilities
for menstrual hygiene, dedicated facilities and equipment for all children, irrespective of the health
status.
The categorization of the social risk listed below addresses the demolition and reconstruction works that
will be involved in the project, organized under three stages (1) pre-construction, (2) demolition and
construction work, (3) post-construction.
Project preparation
▪ Reduced access of vulnerable categories in consultations and project information related to
the Valea Lupului investment. By vulnerable groups, the Project understands: children and
families living in poverty, elderly, children and persons with disabilities, women, Roma children
and adults, children with special educational needs. The project not only aims at avoiding or
mitigating adverse impacts on these categories, that could potentially be more impacted by the
Project, but seeks to create development opportunities for the marginalized. In the case of the
community of Valea Lupului, vulnerable groups are considered to be children and families living
in poverty, children with disabilities and special educational needs, Roma children and their
families.
▪ Lack of specific measures to accommodate the needs of students/teachers with disabilities
and children with special educational needs in the sub-project design. The inclusion
component of the Project enhances universal access design so that people with health conditions
or impairments can enjoy all the benefits provided by the new school, including adapted
furniture, dedicated spaces for counseling and inclusive technology solutions. The proposals that
came from the community during the first round of consultations is expected to be included in
the design specifications.
▪ Reduced access to education for relocated children, in case the mobile classrooms are non-
compliant with health and safety requirements and the functional needs of the educational
23 | P a g e
Pagina 24
process (e.g., fire safety, sanitation, lack of heating, lack of sound proofing, lack of light, etc.). Any
faults that are not taken into account during design and construction risk to reduce children’s
access to education.
Construction of the new school
▪ General discomfort generated by dust and noise pollution, for the children and staff of the
neighboring kindergarten, near-by residents or passers-by;
▪ Community health and safety risks generated by the construction site, in the form of possible
accidents, especially in relation to children learning and playing next to the site, in situations
involving lack of fencing and security measures to restrict access on the construction site, risk of
road accidents for pedestrians in general, and for children, generated by temporary heavy
transport during the construction process;
▪ Disruptions in utility services due to accidents or planned interventions (water, sewerage,
electricity, gas);
▪ Occupational accidents on the construction site, especially in relation to migrant workers, if
the case; the construction sector in Romania continues to be the sector with the highest rates of
work-related accidents and fatalities, due to the lack of compliance with health and safety rules
on site. In relation to the increased number of foreign workers, these persons are likely to be more
exposed to occupational accidents due to language barriers;
▪ Social tensions, increased risks of sexual harassment, abuse and violence, misconduct
during works, potentially perpetuated by construction workers. This impact will likely be greater
in the event of installing temporary accommodation for construction staff, given the proximity of
the site to current educational activities; the risk is related to a gender-based violence risks. The
screening process that concluded the need to protect the local community, especially children
and women, from such situations that might be generated by the presence of contracted workers
in Valea Lupului.
Post-construction phase
▪ Lack of opportunities for vulnerable groups to benefit from the investment, such as Roma, in
particular Roma children, children with disabilities, , community at large. The risk considers the
demographic increase of school aged children in Valea Lupului and relies on the current
segregation practices that are affecting disadvantaged categories across the country. The school
will also have the potential to become a community asset that can be used by various groups
outside of the educational activities, irrespective of their status within the community. Other risks
related to vulnerable categories are the lack of specific equipment to accommodate the needs of
children with disabilities and special educational needs, or the misuse of the menstrual hygiene
units for teenage girls.
▪ Reduced disaster awareness in relation to the role the newly/rehabilitated school can play in
the event of a natural disaster, as well as the process of protecting the life of children and other
community members in the event of an earthquake or other natural disaster. Beyond the
infrastructural component, the project aims at addressing the lack of disaster preventive actions
at the level of the school and the community at large.
▪ Limited availability of the new building and related facilities due to lack of local funds to
cover associated facilities that do not fall under the investment as well as day to day operational
and maintenance expenses of the new school; the proposed designs are aiming to create energy
efficient buildings that are likely to reduce the current operational expenses of local budgets.
Associated investments that will be carried by the local authority (fencing, alleys, courtyard
24 | P a g e
Pagina 25
lighting, landscaping, playgrounds) will be captured in the proposed design and will be planned
in advance so that the new school building is ready to use at the end of Project investments.
Social risks identified under Associated Facilities
Given the focus of the project on enhancing the safety of children learning in schools with considerable
seismic risk, some of the associated investments, such as demolition of current buildings and clearing the
current site from the annexes, fencing, alleys, parking lots, courtyard lighting, playground area,
landscaping at the site of the new school, will be carried technically and financially by the local
authorities.
The risks that pertain from this activity are similar in nature as those described above, under the new
construction works, and will be addressed by local authorities:
▪ Community health and safety risks for the all children and staff on the site that hosts the
buildings to be demolished, for sports field and sports hall users, as well as neighbors and
passers-by during demolition activities. Given the close location of the kindergarten there is a risk
of accidents, specific measures will be consulted with the Kindergarten’s representatives and
other relevant parties. Securing the perimeter of the building and managing the heavy traffic are
also considered essential in keeping the safety of children and adults intact during the process.
This will also be applicable to the small interventions carried by the local authority in the new
school’s yard.
▪ Occupational health and safety. As mentioned above, occupational accidents in the
construction sector continue to be an area of high risk for human health, as enforcement of
national legislation tends to be low, especially in works located in rural parts of the country.
▪ General discomfort generated by dust and noise pollution, for children learning and playing
in the kindergarten next to the site, teachers, near-by residents;
▪ Risk of road accidents for pedestrians in general, and for children in particular, generated by
temporary heavy transport during the construction process;
▪ Disruptions in utility services due to accidents or planned interventions (water, sewerage,
electricity).
3.3 Key environmental risks and impacts
Screening and permitting processes
An initial screening was performed by the City Hall and afterwards was revised by Environmental and
Social Safeguards Specialists of the PMU. Site visits and consultations with the school and local authorities
representatives further supported the data collection process.
Further environmental impacts will be highlighted in the permitting process the Environmental Impact
Assessment procedure which will be conducted by the County Environmental Protection Agency based
on the documents provided by Technical Design Consultant and results will be incorporated into the
current Environmental and Social Management Plan, if necessary.
Environmental Screening results
▪ Valea Lupului is located in Moldavian Plane, in Jijia River basin. School location is inside a 5319
sqm plot, being the Public ownership of Locality;
25 | P a g e
Pagina 26
▪ The land plot allocated for the investment is located outside the area with 0,1% flooding
probability of Bahlui river. Lupul river has not associated flooding events in plot area. (Fig. 7)6 .
No landslide associated probability was identified;
▪ Extensive land clearing will be performed during demolition works;
▪ Hazards to public traffic and pedestrian by transportation vehicles during construction activities.
Entrance and exit of transportation vehicles to working site should be managed;
Fig 7. Flooding hazard map
Environmental risks identified under Project Activities
Demolition and construction work
▪ Pollution with dust, noise and noxious emissions;
▪ Transportation and construction vehicles impact on pedestrian and general traffic;
▪ Improper management of waste resulted from demolition/construction works;
▪ Asbestos impact during demolition of building (low probability);
▪ Improper management of Sewage waters from working site and Leakages from equipment used
on working site;
▪ Not following the indicated procedure in case of discovering a physical cultural, historical or
archaeological resource during excavation or demolition.
Operation of the new school
▪ Improper waste management by not allocating enough recipients for selective collection and
storage of waste (household, plastic, glass, metal, paper, electric and electronic waste) - low
probability;
▪ Unsafe practices during operation of the building by improper connections to the sewage network
- low probability.
6 https://rowater.ro/despre-noi/descrierea-activitatii/managementul-situatiilor-de-urgenta/directiva-inundatii2007-60-ce/harti-de-hazard-si-risc-la-inundatii/, accessed July 2023
26 | P a g e
Pagina 27
The mitigation measures proposed by the Project with the aim of avoiding or reducing as much as
possible the impacts and risks listed above are included in the management plan below, that defines
impact areas, mitigation measures and institutional responsibilities associated with the proposed
measures.
Environmental Guidance
Energy Efficiency, Insulation and Ventilation
Insulation should be tailored to the seasonal impacts of climate, internal thermal load, and characteristics
of exposure. Vapor barriers should prevent moisture intrusion in the roof insulation and outer wall
cavities and using damp course.
Window location should be determined on view, ventilation, light, thermal gain, privacy control and
interior space functions.
High-efficiency systems for heating domestic water (including solar systems) and for interior space
heating should be selected with maintenance and long-term running costs in mind.
Plumbing should be coordinated to minimize plumbing and also water service to toilets and utility rooms.
Water-saving faucets, ring mains and other devices also require consideration. Construction materials
will conform to national regulations and internationally accepted standards of safety and environmental
impacts.
Electrical Systems
Incoming cables should be located underground. Main entrance feed and panel located away from places
of work and waiting is prudent in avoidance of electromagnetic fields. Ground faulty wiring near any
plumbing fixture is a precaution. Selecting the most energy efficient light fixtures, lamps, appliances and
equipment will reduce energy demand but can introduce undesirable electromagnetic fields. Be aware
that close proximity to table, floor and desk halogen, fluorescent and other high-efficiency fixtures and
lamps can cause an exposure to harmful electromagnetic fields.
Selection of Construction Materials and Construction Methods
Environmentally sound goods and services should be selected. Priority should be given to products
meeting standards for recognized international or national symbols. Traditionally well-tried materials
and methods should be chosen before new and unknown techniques. Construction sites should be fenced
off in order to prevent entry of public, and general safety measures would be imposed. Temporary
inconveniences due to construction works should be minimized through planning and coordination with
contractors, neighbors and authorities. In densely populated areas, noisy or vibration generating
activities should be strictly confined to the daytime.
Handling of Waste
The handling of construction debris will be according to local and national regulations, and as specified
in the ESMP, and described above under site considerations. These regulations are developed and
enforceable in Romania. Monitoring will be the responsibility of site supervisors working for the MoE.
For asbestos and asbestos-containing materials please see Annex 1. In all the specific cases for which
contractors should demolish or remove asbestos-containing materials, these categories of works should
be done only with qualified personnel and fully in line with the specific legislation related to this specific
field.
27 | P a g e
Pagina 28
Occupational Health and Safety at Work
The contractor has the obligation to ensure all necessary personal protective equipment (PPE) and
materials, and the workers have the obligation to use all such protective equipment - helmets, gloves,
goggles where appropriate and work uniforms. All these minimum protection rules, doubled by avoiding
over-exhaustion of workers, prevent ergonomic injuries and other work-related accidents resulting from
repetitive, excessive and manual handling of building materials.
Recommendations for their prevention and control include knowledge of the most common causes of
wounds in construction and decommissioning by:
▪ Training of workers in the lifting and handling of materials, techniques in construction and
decommissioning projects, including placement of weight limits over which mechanical
assistance is required;
▪ Workplace site planning to minimize the need for manual heavy load transfer;
▪ Selecting tools and designing workstations that reduce the need for strength;
▪ Implement administrative controls in work processes, such as job rotation and rest breaks.
Contractor H&SP and ERP
Contractor will be required to produce a Health and Safety Plan (H&SP) and an Emergency Response Plan
(ERP) to protect his employees during the works he shall undertake. This Plan will be reviewed at the
level of the PMU both on Environmental and Social aspects and at the level of the Bank. The Contractor’s
ESMP (C-ESMP) shall be considered when preparing contractor’s H&SP and ERP. Environmental controls
and exposure levels associated with worker protection shall be included in the C-ESMP. Work practices
required by the ESMP are not intended to compromise health and safety in any way. Each H&SP and ERP
will be approved by the Supervising Engineer prior to the contractor commencing works to ensure
adequate health and safety controls and procedures have been developed, that are appropriate to the
works to be undertaken.
3.4 Environmental and Social Management Plan
The mitigation measures proposed by the Project with the aim of avoiding or reducing as much as
possible the impacts and risks listed above are included in the management plan below, that defines
impact areas, mitigation measures and institutional responsibilities associated with the proposed
measures. The plan will be subject to consultations with stakeholders and to updates during
implementation, whenever necessary.
28 | P a g e
Pagina 29
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Pre-construction phase
General E&S Management The Contractor shall develop a Contractors ESMP in accordance with All Contractors
the requirements stipulated throughout the ESMP. C-ESMP will
Risks: unsafe and unsustainable include Labor Management Plan, Occupational Health and Safety
practices during demolition and Plan, Solid Waste Management Plan, Emergency Response Plan;
construction works;
Contractor to provide reports and access to E&S information related
Affected persons: school children to the implementation of this ESMP;
and staff, community members,
workers;
Project Design Ensure all elements derived from consultations are integrated into PMU E&S specialists
the final design, especially universal access features;
Risks: exclusion of community from
project design, risks of accidents for Provide clear elements for community safety in Site Organization Design Consultant
children, community and workers, Plan (fencing, restricted access, site surveillance/security system);
non-compliant plans at the level of
site organization;
Affected persons: vulnerable
categories, school children and staff,
community members, workers;
Safe Relocation of Children Ensure health and safety conditions in relocated space are compliant PMU (applying checklist and
with minimum norms; managing grievances)
Risks: unsafe conditions for Apply health and safety checklist and propose remediation actions in
relocated children and staff, the event of non-compliance;
exclusion of vulnerable categories
from educational activities; Install Grievance Box at the relocated school; Local authority (for remediating
actions and installing grievance
Affected persons: relocated box)
children and staff, vulnerable
29 | P a g e
Pagina 30
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
categories, such as disabled
children/staff;
Construction and Demolition Phase
Community Health and Safety Community Safety Elements in place prior to commencement of Contractor
works and maintained throughout work schedule (fencing,
Risks: lack of safety and protective designation of areas with restricted access, separate access routes
elements resulting in accidents, with ID check-up, clear and visible signaling panels,
access of children in restricted areas; surveillance/security system);
Waste Management Plan, Traffic Management Plan, Worker
Management Plan, OHS Plan, Emergency Response Plan approved by
Affected persons: children, school the PMU;
staff, community living next to Record and communicate any accidents involving community
construction sites; members to the PMU;
Installation of GRM Board and Box next to Construction site; PMU Community Engagement
Specialist
Information Notes submitted to all neighbors in relation to work
schedules and grievance mechanism;
School and local authority
Children Safety Awareness Actions developed at the level of the
school with support from PMU.
Occupational Health and Safety OHS Plan and Emergency Response Plan approved by site manager All Contractors
and all safety elements in place in accordance with national legislation
Risk: occupational accidents, lack of and site management plan;
protective equipment on site, lack of Provide translation of OHS requirements on site for Contractors
contracts and illegal work, lack of employing foreign workers;
appropriate trainings OHS Training plan included in Labor Management Plan;
30 | P a g e
Pagina 31
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Internal Code of conduct and Grievance Mechanism for Workers
Affected persons: workers across disclosed to workers;
all planned demolition and Ensure workers are using Personal Protection Equipment and World
construction works; Bank Health and Safety guidelines are followed;
Inform the PMU of any accidents occurring on site or non-compliance
signaled by the control of designated authorities;
Appropriate signaling and information boards on H&S installed at the
sites;
PMU’s E&S Specialists and PMU’s
Perform ad-hoc site visits to check compliance with national H&S technical area coordinator
requirements;
Pollution with dust, noise and Consult and agree with school and church representatives on All Contractors
noxious emissions avoiding, as much as possible, noise pollution during
educational/religious services;
Risks: unsafe conditions for GRM Board and box installed at site;
educational activities, non-compliant Vehicles and machines will be properly maintained and will have up-
work schedules, disturbances at the to-date technical revisions;
level of neighboring activities; Fencing with acoustic barriers in the school direction;
Covering the transportation vehicles for demolition or excavation
Affected persons: school children materials;
and staff, neighbors; Cleaning wheels of vehicles at the exit from working site; PMU’s Community Engagement
Specialist and Area coordinators
Inform community/neighboring properties on any planned or
accidental interruptions in utility services;
Information Notes submitted to all neighbors in relation to work
schedules and grievance mechanism;
Traffic Management Traffic Management Plan elaborated under the C-ESMP; All Contractors
Organize the transport related to the construction works as to avoid
Risks: road accidents and restricted the hours with high pedestrian traffic next to school (early
access for emergency services; morning/afternoon);
Separate pedestrian access to the school from construction vehicles
accessing the site;
31 | P a g e
Pagina 32
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Affected persons: children, elderly, Install signaling of routes, restricted access and speed limits on site;
community members, neighbors;
Request support from Local Police to assist with children safety
during intense transport schedule, if necessary;
School and local authority
Children Safety Awareness Actions developed at the level of the
school with support from PMU.
Influx of Labor Contractor will comply with PMU’s Labor Management Plan, All Contractors
attached to the bidding documents;
Risks: sexual harassment and abuse Trainings regarding SEA/SH will be provided to all Project workers,
of school children and other based on contractor’s Code of Conduct, signed by all workers;
community members, especially Inform PMU on intention to temporary house workers on site and
girls and women, and female present accommodation plans and features.
workforce, social tensions in the Provide separate facilities for women, if there is female participation
community, illegal work practices; in works on site;
Ensure that all site workers have legal contracting forms, are over 18,
Affected persons: school children, have valid working visa for foreign workers;
girls and women in the community Provide internal grievance mechanism for workers and inform about
and working on site, workers, Project’s GRM;
especially migrant workers; Inform PMU on non-compliances recorded by auditing labor
authorities;
PMU’s Social and Community
The Gender Based Violence Action Plan, including service provider Engagement Specialists
mapping, updated as necessary in the Project’s SEP;
Awareness actions on GBV Plan to be carried at the level of the
school/community, with the support of PMU;
Dedicated grievance channel to capture SEA/SH related complaints
in place;
Waste Management Management of waste from demolition/construction in order to be All contractors
reutilized, recycled and other, for minimum 70% of generated waste;
Risks: pollution; Separated collection of domestic waste in designated areas on
working site;
Affected parts: air and soil
32 | P a g e
Pagina 33
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Contracting authorized companies for waste transport and
management;
Sewage waters from working site Supply of working site with mobile toilets for workers and company All contractors
personnel;
Leakages from equipment used on Using equipment in good conditions to avoid Leakages;
working site Removing contaminated soil, treating and final deposing;
Risks: pollution;
Affected parts: soil and
underground waters;
Clearing the site and removal of Any removal of existing trees will be replanted in a suitable area; All contractors
planted vegetation Restoration of vegetation to the initial state, wherever applicable;
Impact on trees vegetation or
hedgerows
Risks: damages;
Affected parts: vegetation;
Discovering a physical cultural, Stop the construction activities in the area of the chance find; All contractors
historical or archaeological Delineate the discovered site or area and secure the site;
resource during excavation or Notify the Supervising Engineer who in turn will notify the
demolition responsible authorities immediately (within 24 hours or less);
Construction works could resume only after permission is
Risks: damages;
granted from the responsible local authorities concerning
Affected parts: cultural heritage; safeguard of the physical cultural resource;
33 | P a g e
Pagina 34
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Asbestos impact during In case of finding asbestos and asbestos-containing materials during Contracted companies for
demolition of building demolition - contract with authorized companies for handling, collection, demolition works
transportation and disposal;
Risks: pollution;
Affected persons: workers;
Post Construction Phase
Lack of opportunities for Consult school and parents on inclusive school furniture during PMU’s Community Engagement
vulnerable groups acquisition phase; Specialist
Consult girls on menstrual hygiene practices and provisions in the
Risks: lack of adapting the dedicated spaces in the new buildings;
equipment to the needs of Consult with vulnerable groups if there are instances of exclusion or
vulnerable children, especially discrimination in relation to accessing the new school;
children with disabilities and special Ensure acquisition documents reflect community perspectives
educational needs, vulnerable girls; derived from all consultations;
Affected persons: children with
disabilities and special educational
needs, girls coming from poor
families;
Limited functionality of the new Detailed design and associated costs will be consulted with the Local PMU Management
building or delays due to lack of authority and financing options will be identified in the Protocol
local funds for associated facilities signed between the parties;
assumed under the PMU-Local Protocol will clearly state the timelines related to the associated
Authority Protocol facilities related to the functionality, accessibility and safety of the
new building and its surroundings;
Risks: lack of universal accessibility
to the new building, lack of safety for
children (especially girls) next to the
school area, lack of connection to
basic utilities;
34 | P a g e
Pagina 35
E&S Impact Area and Risks Proposed mitigation measures Institutional responsibility for
mitigation
Affected persons: school children
and staff, girls, children with
disabilities;
Waste resulted from school Improper waste management due to insufficient allocation of School maintenance staff
activities recipients for selective collection and storage of waste (household,
plastic, glass, metal, paper, electric and electronic waste);
Risks: pollution
Affected parts: air and soil
Leakages of sewage waters Maintenance in good condition of sewage network; School maintenance staff
Risks: pollution;
Affected parts: soil and
underground waters;
35 | P a g e
Pagina 36
4. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
The overall responsibility for implementing the provisions of the current ESMP lies with the PMU
dedicated for this project. All other actors involved in the process, such as contractors, the Valea Lupului
School representatives, local authority, will be informed about their responsibilities and bidding
documents, contracts and protocols will define roles, timelines and actions expected from each
stakeholder.
Definition of roles and responsibilities (PIU/local authorities/Contractors/)
PMU roles and responsibilities in relation with ESMP
The Project Management Unit for the Modernization of the School and University Network (PMUMSUN)
within the Ministry of Education acts as the Project Implementing Agency. The PMU is responsible for
all Project implementation activities. PMU will be assisted in the process by a TD & TA Consultant,
Contractors for Construction Works, specialized technical verifiers (including environmental verifiers),
site managers, contract managers, who will be contracted in different phases of the Project.
Role of the Technical Design & Technical Assistance Consultant
At the time of writing this report, PMUMSUN have procured the services of a Consultant who would
provide the Technical Design documentation for the demolition and construction works and Technical
Assistance during works execution. In more detail, the Consultant will be responsible with the
development of the Inception Report, with the delivery of the Documentation for obtaining the
Demolition Permit for the existing construction, with the Documentation for obtaining the Building
Permit, with the development of the Technical Design and of the Execution Detail Design for the
proposed construction, and with providing the Technical Assistance Services for the works execution,
as well as preparing the necessary documentations for obtaining the operational permits, and other
necessary services in order to achieve the investment objective of the Valea Lupului School. In relation
to the ESMP, the Consultant will be responsible of:
Supervision of the quality of the works, including compliance with Law No. 10/1995 - in terms
of following requirements:
A- Mechanical strength and stability
B - Fire safety
C - Hygiene, health and environment
D - Safety and accessibility in operation
E - Noise protection
F - Energy saving and thermal insulation
The worksite organization (including details on waste management, sewerage during works,
separate toilets, dining and resting spaces, health and safety signage, grievance board, project
information board, fencing, restricted access);
Provide the specifications for the works, where ESMP provisions should be included.
The PMU E&S experts will be involved in regular meetings with the Consultant, and will participate in
site visits together, review the monthly reports submitted by the Consultant in relation to ESMP
provisions, and update the ESMP based on details and specifications that will have surfaced during the
technical design phase. An initial public consultation took place in March 2023 and a second
36 | P a g e
Pagina 37
consultation is planned while disclosing this document, presenting the proposed final design of the new
school, allowing the participation of the public in the design and planning process.
Role of the Environmental, Social and Community Engagement Specialists
Environmental, Social and Community Engagement Specialists within PMUMSUN will be responsible
for disclosure, consultation, coordination and supervision of the ESMP and risk mitigation measures
undertaken within the project. The Specialists will work in close coordination with supervision project
coordination staff and technical staff in courts and will:
disseminate existing environmental and social management guidelines and develop guidelines
in relation to issues not covered by the existing regulations, in line with the Bank and EU
standards for implementation, monitoring and evaluation of mitigation measures;
ensure that procurement processes for construction works and supply of equipment include
reference to appropriate guidelines and standards;
conduct periodic site visits to inspect and approve plans and monitor compliance;
ensure the uniformity in all activities related to the preparation and implementation
of Environmental and Social Management Plans;
keep permanent contact with Environmental and Social safeguards specialists of the World
Bank and ask for advice on any problem that requires guidance regarding the activity in the
field.
In particular the Environmental Specialist will:
perform activities related to compliance of environmental activities;
prepare activity plans for Environmental impact mitigation of the construction activity
outcomes and the Environmental monitoring plan;
ensure that the systematic supervision in relation with qualitative and quantitative indicators
and perform analysis for underlining the achievements and the evolution of the implementation
process is done by Contractors according to the monitoring plan;
prepare periodical reports for the World Bank and Government Agencies;
coordinate environmental training for staff, designers and local contractors, related to
responsibilities on environmental protection.
In particular the Social Specialist will:
ensure that the terms of reference for any design consultancy services incorporate the World
Bank safeguards and corporate requirements including public disclosure and public
consultation on the results of environmental and social impact assessments, citizen engagement
and gender aspects;
be responsible for carrying out activities related to social safeguards within the framework of
component 1 of the project in accordance with the provisions of the loan agreement;
manage the GRM, and ensures that each complaint is handled in accordance with the procedure;
reviews the complaints received and recommends appropriate measures to deal with the issues
raised, as appropriate; monitor the social impact of the Project and propose measures to
properly manage the risks generated by the implementation activities.
In particular the Community Engagement Specialist will:
identify the stakeholders and organize stakeholder engagement activities that will be targeted
at project affected persons as well as at other interested parties;
be responsible of the communications, consultations and engagement with direct beneficiaries
and the wider public;
ensure outreach to and engagement of disadvantaged and vulnerable groups;
37 | P a g e
Pagina 38
establish and manage public meetings, trainings and workshops, media and social media
communication, disclosure of written materials, as well as a survey among affected persons to
gauge satisfaction with the quality of citizen engagement and share additional concerns.
Role of the Contractors
The contractor shall be responsible for implementing the provisions under the ESMP. The final version
of the ESMP, with updated actions based on the technical design and specifications provided by the
TD&TA Consultant, will be approved after the contribution of the public, collected during public
disclosure and consultations and organized during the technical design phase. Once the contract is
signed, with the ESMP acting as an annex, the Contractor can bring contributions to the plan, following
negotiations with the E&S experts within the PMU and the TD&TA Consultant.
Contractor ESMP (C-ESMP)
The demolition and construction contractors will prepare their own ESMP based on the framework of
the approved site-specific ESMP. The C-ESMP will be reviewed and approved by the Supervising
Engineer and will form part of the contractual obligations. The C-ESMP will be specific to the contracted
services but will consider the impact of these services at the level of the construction sites.
Worksite organization
Constructor will implement all the aspects from the works project design including details on waste
management, sewerage during works, separate toilets, dining and resting spaces, health and safety
signage, grievance board, project information board, fencing, restricted access.
Occupational Health and Safety at Work
The contractor has the obligation to ensure all necessary protective equipment and materials, and the
workers have the obligation to use all such protective equipment - helmets, gloves, goggles where
appropriate and work uniforms. All these minimum protection rules, doubled by avoiding overexhaustion of workers, prevent ergonomic injuries and other work-related accidents resulting from
repetitive, excessive and manual handling of building materials.
Recommendations for their prevention and control include knowledge of the most common causes of
wounds in construction and decommissioning by:
Training of workers in the lifting and handling of materials, techniques in construction and
decommissioning projects, including placement of weight limits over which mechanical
assistance is required;
Workplace site planning to minimize the need for manual heavy load transfer;
Selecting tools and designing workstations that reduce the need for strength;
Implement administrative controls in work processes, such as job rotation and rest breaks.
Contractor H&SP and ERP
Contractor will be required to produce a Health and Safety Plan (H&SP) and an Emergency Response
Plan (ERP) to protect his employees during the works he shall undertake. The C-ESMP shall be
considered when preparing contractor’s H&SP and ERP. Environmental controls and exposure levels
associated with worker protection shall be included in the contractor’s ESMP. Work practices required
by the ESMP are not intended to compromise health and safety in any way. Each H&SP and ERP will be
approved by the Supervising Engineer prior to the contractor commencing works to ensure adequate
health and safety controls and procedures have been developed, that are appropriate to the works to
be undertaken.
38 | P a g e
Pagina 39
The bidding documents will include requirements related to all plans, strategies and resources allocated
for the current ESMP compliance. The ESMF that informs the current ESMP contains detailed
information about legal obligations, World Bank requirements and specific guidelines for Contractors
to develop all necessary documents.
Role of the Site Manager
The site manager will facilitate the monitoring visits and will need to be organized in accordance with
the ESMP provisions. The bidding documents for the procurement of the site managers will include
revisions from the E&S experts within the PMU.
Role of the Local Authority
The local authority in Valea Lupului will be responsible with contracting and monitoring the E&S
performance of demolition and construction works carried for the Associated Facilities. This
responsibility will be subject to the Protocol signed between the PMU and the local authority. Trainings
will be provided to ensure that compliance of this ESMP are reflected in bidding documents. Monitoring
of E&S aspects will be carried by the local authority, with support and supervision from the PMU.
Role of the Valea Lupului School
The Valea Lupului School will assist the PMU with the implementation of awareness campaigns aimed
at preparing children and staff in relation to safety next to the construction site, disaster risk campaigns,
gender based violence risks and the grievance mechanism at the level of the Project.
39 | P a g e
Pagina 40
5. THE PLAN FOR MONITORING SOCIAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS
Monitoring plan for risks/mitigation measures
The mitigation measures proposed under the social and environmental management plan (ESMP) will
be monitored by the responsible entities during the implementation of the sub-project, as described in
the Monitoring Plan below.
Monitoring activities aim at:
monitoring and reporting on the effectiveness of the mitigation measures and responsibilities
identified and achieved;
informing about the need to extend, intensify or adjust mitigation measures;
identifying any new areas potentially exposed to the environmental and social impact that have
not been taken into account in the ESMP.
Monitoring will begin with the construction work and will be implemented at all stages of the project.
A presentation of the social and environmental monitoring plan is presented below.
The monitoring plan will be updated, if needed, once all permitting is obtained or during
implementation, if unexpected impacts generate new mitigation measures in the management plan.
40 | P a g e
Pagina 41
Environmental and Social Monitoring Plan
E&S Measures/ Monitoring Actions Monitoring Institutional responsibility for
Parameters Frequency monitoring
Pre-Construction
General E&S Management C-ESMP has been developed and Approved; Once (prior to PMU’s E&S Specialists
construction works)
Project Design Detailed design incorporates community perspectives Once (finalization of PMU’s E&S Specialists
from consultations and specific safety features for detailed design)
community safety;
Relocated School’s Safety Health and safety Checklist completed and remediation Once (as soon as Local authority with technical
actions (if necessary) implemented; practical) support from PMU
GRM Box installed at relocated school;
Construction/Demolition Works
Community Health and Community Safety Elements in place at Once (prior to PMU’s E&S Specialists
Safety construction/demolition sites; commencement of
works) and during
site visits
Recorded Grievances on site/other channels and recorded Weekly PMU
accidents and their resolution;
Report on community health and safety; Monthly Contractors
Children Safety Awareness Actions implemented; Once (prior to PMU Community Engagement
construction works) Specialist
41 | P a g e
Pagina 42
E&S Measures/ Monitoring Actions Monitoring Institutional responsibility for
Parameters Frequency monitoring
and according to
agreed plans
Information Notes on Work Schedule distributed to Once (prior to PMU Community engagement
affected stakeholders; construction works) Specialist
Occupational Health and Occupational H&S elements in place (PPE, first aid, Once (prior to works PMU E&S Specialists and Area
Safety training list, H&S responsible, signaling, code of conduct, commencement) and Coordinator
etc.) assessed during site visits; during site visits
Daily
Contractors’ H&S expert
Reports on occupational health and safety; Monthly Contractors’ H&S expert
General discomfort Construction and demolition works carried in accordance Daily Contractors
generated by dust and noise within agreed timelines and hours;
pollution at the level of
school/neighboring area
Recorded Grievances on site/other channels and recorded During Site Visits PMU’s Social and Community
accidents and their resolution; and when grievances Engagement Specialist
are recorded
Compliance with noise and dust mitigations measures; Daily Contractor
During site visits PMU’s Environmental Specialist
Traffic Management Separated access, signaling and driver’s safety training in Once (prior to Contractor
place; construction works)
During site visits
42 | P a g e
Pagina 43
E&S Measures/ Monitoring Actions Monitoring Institutional responsibility for
Parameters Frequency monitoring
Compliance of traffic measures; PMU
Influx of Labor Trainings on Code of Conduct (including GBV) and Once (prior to Contractor
Contractor’s Grievance Mechanism for Workers construction works)
performed for all workers on site;
Resolution of grievances related to conduct of workers Whenever PMU’s Social and Community
(including GBV) in the school area/community; grievances are engagement specialists
recorded
Compliance with Labor Management Plan attached to During site visits PMU’s Social Specialist
contract;
Collection and transport of Review the transportation list and conditions at the Before the Environmental Specialist of
demolition or hazardous storage facility; transportation of the Contracted company for
waste (including asbestos) hazardous waste demolition and construction
works
Environmental Safeguards
Specialist of PMU
Dust, noise and noxious Visual checks and according with the procedure for During the Environmental Specialist of
emission demolition; demolition phase Contracted company for
and clean-up demolition works / Constructor
activities Area coordinator of the PMU
Environmental Safeguards
Specialist of PMU
Good functioning of Visual checks and according with the procedure for During the Environmental Specialist of
construction machinery demolition; demolition phase Contracted company for
and clean-up demolition works / Constructor
activities Area coordinator of the PMU
Environmental Safeguards
Specialist of PMU
43 | P a g e
Pagina 44
E&S Measures/ Monitoring Actions Monitoring Institutional responsibility for
Parameters Frequency monitoring
The safety protection Visual checks; At the beginning of Contractors’ H&S expert
measures applied for the each working day
workers during the project
activities
During site visits Area coordinator of the PMU
Discovering a physical Reported discoveries during demolition/excavation; During demolition Contractor
cultural resource, such as and excavations Environmental Safeguards
(but not limited to) Specialist of PMU
archeological sites,
historical sites, remains and
objects, or a cemetery
and/or individual graves
during excavation or
construction
Asbestos impact during Records of quantity of asbestos materials discovered; Whenever such Contractor
demolition of building discoveries are made Environmental Safeguards
Specialist of PMU
Post-Construction
Lack of opportunities for Consultations with vulnerable groups implemented; Once (prior to PMU’s Community Engagement
vulnerable groups acquisition of Expert
equipment)
Reduced awareness in Completed trainings at the level of the school; Once (at the roll-out PMU
relation to the role that the of the trainings)
newly/rehabilitated school
can play in the event of a Report on community event and actions carried at the Once PMU
natural disaster opening of the school;
Waste resulted from school Verification of Separated collection of waste and e-waste Monthly School administrative staff
activities in designated area;
44 | P a g e
Pagina 45
E&S Measures/ Monitoring Actions Monitoring Institutional responsibility for
Parameters Frequency monitoring
Leakage of Sewage waters Checking the sewage collection systems; Monthly School administrative staff
45 | P a g e
Pagina 46
6. STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT AND INFORMATION DISCLOSURE
The project is expected to have a minimal negative impact on neighboring properties. However, the
noise and dust from the construction, the process of relocation of students and other inconveniences
that can be experienced by the local community in Valea Lupului as a result of demolition and
construction work are elements that show that the project affects the lives of others and all necessary
measures must be taken to keep in touch with those affected, to understand their fears, discomfort and
to consider their suggestions in order to mitigate as much as possible the adverse impact on them.
In earlier stages of the project, consultations were held with representatives of local authorities,
schools, teachers and representatives of students and parents, during which general information about
the project, the site plan and the proposed construction in terms of spaces and functions, and the
facilities proposed to make the building safer, sustainable and inclusive were presented.
The parties interested or affected by the works to be carried out under the Valea Lupului sub-project
identified at this stage are listed below:
▪ Children and staff of the school and parents of the children;
▪ The Student Council of Valea Lupului School;
▪ Parent Representative Committee;
▪ Representatives of the School Council;
▪ Children and staff of the kindergarten and parents of the children;
▪ People living in the vicinity of the site;
▪ Citizens potentially affected by the interruption of utilities during the works.
Other Interested Parties:
▪ Local authorities in Valea Lupului: the city mayor, social assistance department, Local police;
▪ “Friends of Valea Lupului School” Association;
▪ Representatives of the Roma community in Valea Lupului;
▪ Workers and experts who will carry out activities and works on site;
▪ The population of Valea Lupului;
▪ Local NGOs on social development and environment protection (Asociația Împreună Pentru O
Comunitate Activă, Partida Romilor Pro-Europa, ANCAAR Iași, Asociația Mai Bine);
▪ Media outlets in Valea Lupului and Iasi;
▪ Environmental Agency, Environmental Guard;
▪ Iași County School Inspectorate;
▪ Iași County Center for Educational Assistance and Resources.
Vulnerable groups
The Community Vulnerability Assessment carried during Project preparation revealed that
disadvantaged/vulnerable individuals and groups relevant to the project fall into two broad
categories: on one hand, there are vulnerable subgroups among the selected schools’ students; on
the other, there are vulnerable subgroups within the local communities.
Within the school communities, it appears that the following groups would be particularly
vulnerable: children from poor rural areas, children from Roma groups, children from other
ethnicities, pregnant girls and young mothers, school dropouts, children with special educational
needs, children with physical disabilities, distressed children, bullied kids.
46 | P a g e
Pagina 47
At the level of the community, persons or groups that would be particularly vulnerable include
people with visual or hearing impairments, Illiterate community members or members with low
education levels, working parents of schoolchildren, etc.
Regarding the Valea Lupului sub-project, the involvement of interested parties and the
dissemination of information will be adapted to the specific needs of the Roma community in the
nearby settlement, children with disabilities and special educational needs and their parents,
parents who have difficulties accessing written information, people elderly people who live in the
vicinity of demolition and construction sites.
Stakeholder engagement activities include establishment and management of a project-wide
grievance redress mechanism, public consultations, community events to disclose information and
consult wider audiences, trainings and workshops, media and social media communication,
disclosure of written materials in the village, individual discussions and focus groups with specific
groups, as well as the application of surveys among affected persons to gauge satisfaction with the
quality of citizen engagement and to provide the possibility of different groups to share additional
concerns.
Engagement and communication activities
The communication and engagement activities include information disclosure, public consultations,
media communication and direct interactions with stakeholders as follows:
Updated information on www.umpmrsu.ro about the project implementation, ESMP disclosure,
timing of consultations, grievance mechanism, relocation of students, etc.;
Social media posts and engagement on the Project’s dedicated Facebook page;
Public consultations with relevant stakeholders and affected parties related to the design of the
new school, ESMP, relocation, equipping the school, and whenever necessary;
Information disclosure at the level of the community through posters, announcements on the
local authority and school webpages and social media accounts, information leaflets made
available at school level, use of existing channels for parents and teachers (such as WhatsApp
groups or Facebook groups);
Press releases related to the important stages of the project, including the requirements of the
ESMP and the results of the monitoring efforts related to the compliance with the environmental
and social requirements (for example, public consultations), as necessary;
Email updates sent to stakeholders on stages of the Project, invitations to public consultations,
results of monitoring activities;
Face to face meetings, especially with categories that are under-represented or vulnerable in
relation to the Project (e.g. Roma community members and representatives, elderly persons
affected by the Project, persons having difficulties in accessing written materials or information
made available online).
Consultations carried by the Project
During the project identification and preparation stage in 2020, several consultations took place at the
national level involving with the Council of Students, County School Inspectorates, National Federation
of Parents' Associations, schools, local councils, other agencies and key stakeholders. In addition, an
online survey completed by 480 persons informed the Project about perception of the state of their
school building, the availability of modern teaching resources of the school, the existence of a school
emergency plan, building safety, accessibility and quality, possible challenges linked to the building’s
demolition/reconstruction, preferred channels for information and feedback provision, etc.
47 | P a g e
Pagina 48
Regarding the Valea Lupului sub-project, in 2021 consultations were held with school representatives
and the local authority to identify the needs of the local educational infrastructure at risk.
On 07.03.2023, the initial consultation took place within the SSIS-Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable
Schools Project held at the Valea Lupului School, Iași county. The meeting was attended by the PMU
team made up of 6 members (consultants, designers, PMU coordinator) and the representatives of
interested parties from the community in the number of 18 people: the mayor of the town, the school
director, mayor counsellor, support teacher, representatives of parents, a parent of a children with
special educational needs, librarian, students, teachers, counselors, educators, social workers, scholar
inspector, urbanism inspector.
Fig.8 Photo from the initial public consultation held on March 7, 2023 in Valea Lupului
Discussions were held based on the presentation of the project and the sketches/model made for the
future school. The participants asked various questions on issues related to the relocation of the school
to a much more spacious place, a new location, whether the existing dining hall does not also require
preparation spaces, the community expressed the need to have sports fields and gyms, the issues
related to the streets in the area being particularly narrow, and how this will become a real traffic
problem for the departure and arrival of students and parents; community indicated the growing
population, the presence of many young families with many children who need to go to school. The
architects' proposal of having a building with Gf + 2fF + Attic, was not aligned with the urban planning
provisions which permit buildings with ground floor and two extra floors. The architects proposed a
variant with Semi-basement + Gf + 2F. In relation to the relocation of children in modular spaces, it is
necessary to connect these units to 280 KW power line for heating purposes; in this respect, there were
requests to relocate the new school and keep the students in the existing location until the construction
is completed. The parents of children with SEN consider that the relocation to another area of the school
would be beneficial for students with SEN, they will not be able to adapt to the temporary containers. A
representative of the parents says that the architecture of the new school project is very beautiful, but
there is no more free space for children to play outside, the mayor proposes to give up the dining room
to build more classrooms. All these recommendations were noted down and solutions by the Project’s
team will be presented to the community during the second round of consultations.
48 | P a g e
Pagina 49
"Mihai Dumitriu" Secondary School, Valea Lupului, Iași county
Recommendations that can easily Recommendations for interventions that Recommendations for
be implemented at school level can be addressed at project level interventions beyond the
without additional funding scope of the project that
can be submitted to the
MoE for consideration
No Including the dining room Gym
Semi-basement+GF+2F
shrinking classrooms’ area and increasing
their number
Moving the administrative spaces in the
semi-basement area
relocation of the new
school on the current site
to facilitate road access to
the area
The final conclusion was a positive one regarding the school's appearance, interior details, the "open
school" concept, future facilities for laboratories, exhibition areas, but the focus of the discussions was
on the change of the school's location to a nearby area where there is a piece of land belonging to the
municipality, part of which was obtained by expropriation. However, given that the expropriation was
not accepted under the project, and that the school was selected based on the confirmation that it owned
the public land for investment at the time of submitting the application under the Project, the
municipality accepted the adaptation of the new school to the local urban planning provisions to include
a semi-basement, Ground Floor, and 2 Floors, the reduction of the classrooms dimensions and the
increase of their number, the relocation of the administrative areas in the semi-basement, the
repositioning of the new school on the current land to facilitate road access.
49 | P a g e
Pagina 50
7. INVOLVEMENT OF INTERESTED PARTIES
This ESMP is subject to a consultation process. The document is disclosed on the Project website from
August 2023 for a period of 10 days. During this period, any interested stakeholders can provide
feedback to the document, identified risks and proposed mitigation and monitoring actions, through the
various channels provided by the Project.
Once published on the website, the document was disseminated by the school and the local authority,
especially targeting teachers and parents of children who will be affected by the investment.
Additionally, an informative poster promoted the public consultation, being displayed both at the Town
Hall and the school.
The public consultation took place at Valea Lupului Primary School on August 3, 2023, and was open to
all interested parties.
The meeting was attended by the team of the Project Management Unit for the Modernization of the
School and University Network, consisting of 7 members (PMU coordinator, social consultant,
environmental consultant, area technical coordinator, designer, technical specialist, monitoring
specialist), as well as representatives of the stakeholders from the community, totaling 11 participants:
representatives of the Municipality (mayor, local councilor, urbanism inspector, cadastral inspector),
representative of Iași County School Inspectorate, school representatives (principal, chief secretary,
teachers, students).
Main topics: - Consultation on the Environmental and Social Management Plan
- Presentation of the final version of the technical project
During the meeting, aspects related to the Environmental and Social Management Plan were discussed,
including the enumeration of environmental and social risks, their impact, and measures for their
mitigation.
The final version of the technical project was presented and plans and renderings of the new building
were showcased.
The proposed construction will have a basement, ground floor, and two additional floors, with a built
area of approximately 1300 sqm and a total area of approximately 4600 sqm. It will be equipped with
fire detection, alarm, and signaling systems, as well as an indoor and outdoor hydrant system. The
proposed functions include 22 classrooms, 3 laboratories, a CDI space, a library, a dining hall designed
for serving meals in three shifts through catering, a medical room for consultations and treatments,
equipped with an isolation chamber, a psychological counseling room with a space for calming children
with special educational needs, an administrative area for teaching staff located on the ground floor,
consisting of an office, two director's offices, an archive, and other necessary spaces. The maximum
capacity of the educational unit is 572 students.
The building's superstructure will be made of reinforced concrete frames. Photovoltaic panels and other
necessary equipment for climate control will be installed on the roof. Exterior closures will be made of
BCA masonry. Both exterior and interior carpentry will be made of aluminum and glass. The interior
lighting system will consist of LED fixtures, and spaces used intermittently will be equipped with
sensors and timers. Heating and cooling energy as well as hot water will be produced using renewable
sources (solar panels and heat pumps), and the sanitary installations will focus on reducing
consumption and will be equipped with sensors. The building is equipped with an elevator for the
mobility of persons with disabilities.
50 | P a g e
Pagina 51
Fig.9 Photo from the public consultation held on August 3, 2023 in Valea Lupului
Conclusions: The participants appreciated the involvement of the project implementation team, with
the school's technical plan being very suitable for the children's needs, especially those with disabilities
and special educational needs. The organization of a community event proposed by the social specialist
is being considered as well as the set up of a permanent information point.
51 | P a g e
Pagina 52
8. GRIEVANCES MECHANISM
Within the project, a notification management and resolution system was developed, with the aim of
allowing the implementation team to receive information from the people affected by the project and
to be able to respond to their requests, thus managing, in an efficient way, the impact the project during
its implementation. On the project's website, there is a procedure on the complaint resolution
mechanism, which details the process at the PMU level.
Grievances related to the project can be submitted via several channels, as follows:
PMU level: The main four channels for receiving grievances are by website form, phone, e-mail and
mail at the level of the PMU. This ensures that the PMU has an immediate control over all project related
grievances and can address the raised issues immediately. The phone number of the secretariat will be
available on working hours.
Website form: www.umpmrsu.ro
Email: [email protected]
GBV Email*: [email protected]
Phone Number: +(4)(021) 310 22 07
Address: UMPMRSU, Spiru Haret, nr. 12, Sector 1, București
*In the case of complaints related to gender-based violence, additional attention will be paid to the
confidentiality and sensitivity of this type of petition. In order to ensure a fair and objective resolution
of the issues complained of by the complainant, the Project has established the use of a dedicated email
address, as well as a clear procedure for referring victims to specialized services provided by public and
private entities.
School Level: Stakeholders, affected persons, including students or parents, can submit their
grievances/suggestions at the school level through the grievance box that will be made available on
both the location of the construction site and the relocation site. These grievance boxes will be installed
at the time of relocation and beginning of works, and will be accompanied by a board describing the
Project and the current GRM and presenting all the channels that are available for the public to submit
their grievances.
In person: To ensure that the GRM is accessible to persons, that have no digital equipment or that have
low literacy levels, the Project provides the option to report complaint/feedback to the regional
coordinator or the PMU’s social specialist based on special dedicated feedback/grievance sessions
organized at local level. This option will be explored during public consultations and will be enacted
only when the scale of the impacts and the socio-economic conditions require for such an approach.
Such sessions will be announced in a timely manner and will be organized in an accessible location for
the affected persons.
The citizens will also have the option to address directly to PMUMSUN headquarters by planning a visit
with the social specialist or project manager in person.
Grievance mailboxes will be installed next to the school investment board before the commencement
of works at the level of each school site. The mailbox will be verified weekly by the area coordinator and
any grievances submitted by this channel will be sent immediately to the PMUMSUN by internal post.
World Bank GRS
The GRS ensures that complaints received are promptly reviewed in order to address project-related
concerns. The project affected communities and individuals may submit their complaint to the WB’s
independent Inspection Panel which determines whether harm occurred, or could occur, as a result of
52 | P a g e
Pagina 53
WB non-compliance with its policies and procedures. Complaints may be submitted at any time after
concerns have been brought directly to the World Bank's attention, and Bank Management has been
given an opportunity to respond.
For information on how to submit complaints to the World Bank’s corporate Grievance Redress Service
(GRS), please visit http://www.worldbank.org/GRS.
For information on how to submit complaints to the World Bank Inspection Panel, please visit
www.inspectionpanel.org.
53 | P a g e
Pagina 54
ANNEX 1 - REQUIREMENTS AND MEASURES WHEN HANDLING ASBESTOS
Asbestos is a group of naturally occurring fibrous silicate minerals. It was once used widely in the
production of many industrial and household products because of its useful properties, including fire
retardation, electrical and thermal insulation, chemical and thermal stability, and high tensile strength.
Today, however, asbestos is recognized as a cause of various diseases and cancers and is considered a
health hazard if inhaled. Because the health risks associated with exposure to asbestos area now widely
recognized, global health and worker organizations, research institutes, and some governments have
enacted bans on the commercial use of asbestos.
In the European Union the use of asbestos is banned since January 1, 2005, and in Romania through a
Governmental Decision no. 734/2006 this was banned only for new materials. Products containing
asbestos and which have been installed or were in operation before the date 1 January 2005 can be used
until the end of their lifecycle.
Good practice is to minimize the health risks associated with ACM by avoiding their use in new
construction and renovation, and, if installed asbestos-containing materials are encountered, by using
internationally recognized standards and best practices to mitigate their impact. In all cases, the World
Bank expects borrowers and other clients to use alternative materials wherever feasible. ACM must be
avoided in new construction.
In reconstruction, demolition, and removal of damaged infrastructure, asbestos hazards must be
identified and a risk management plan adopted that includes disposal techniques and end-of-life sites.
Asbestos-containing (AC) products include flat panels, corrugated panels used for roofing, water
storage tanks, water, and sewer pipes etc. Thermal insulation containing asbestos and sprayed asbestos
for insulation and acoustic damping were widely used through the 1970s and should be looked for in
any project involving boilers and insulated pipes.
As asbestos is often used in construction (mainly for roofing) in many countries including Romania, it
can present a risk for the health of workers and population, who live near buildings that need capital
repair with replacement of roofing or demolition.
PMU specialists must inform beneficiaries on potential risk for their health and instruct not using
asbestos as construction material during construction/rehabilitation works.
Any asbestos product or material that is ready for disposal is defined as asbestos waste. Asbestos waste
also includes contaminated building materials, tools that cannot be decontaminated, personal
protective equipment and damp rags used for cleaning. Always this type of waste must be treated as
‘Hazardous Waste’.
In this regards, ACM and asbestos waste must be properly removed, stored in a separate closed area
and disposed (with the consent of local administration and environmental inspectors) on a landfill on
the special area for disposal of that type of waste.
PMU must require the contractors that the removal, repair, and disposal of ACM shall be carried out in
a way that minimizes worker and community asbestos exposure. During reconstruction works, workers
must avoid destroying asbestos sheets and properly dispose them at construction sites until final
disposal happens. Workers must wear protective over garment, gloves and respirators during work
with asbestos sheets. Proper disposal of ACM is important not only to protect the community and
environment but also to prevent scavenging and reuse of removed material. ACM must be transported
in leak tight containers to a secure landfill operated in a manner that precludes air and water
contamination that could result from ruptured containers. The removal and disposal of ACM and
asbestos waste as well as all other ESMP measures have to be included in both the technical
specifications and bill of quantities (BoQs). Contractor shall develop site-specific ESMP where
requirements to ACM and asbestos waste will be contained.
54 | P a g e
Pagina 55
ANNEX 2 - PROCEDURE FOR MANAGEMENT OF PHYSICAL CULTURAL RESOURCES –
PROTECTION AND CHANCE FIND PROCEDURES
Project construction activities have the potential to result in negative impacts on both tangible and
nontangible cultural heritage, which can be held as highly valuable within local communities and often
also at a regional level. Some cultural heritage sites may also be tourist attractions that help support
local economies. The Project and ESMF seeks to proactively manage, avoid or limit any negative impacts
on cultural heritage and to this effect has included specific obligations regarding cultural heritage in the
tender documents issued to potential Contractors.
Activities, such as trenching that may result in psychical impacts on culturally significant structures or
artifacts, including currently unknown artifacts, or construction could cause disruption to cultural
practices due to obstruction of access to cultural sites.
If any person discovers a physical cultural resource, such as (but not limited to) archeological sites,
historical sites, remains and objects, or a cemetery and/or individual graves during excavation or
construction, the Contractor shall:
1. Stop the construction activities in the area of the chance find;
2. Delineate the discovered site or area;
3. Secure the site to prevent any damage or loss of removable objects. In cases of removable antiquities
or sensitive remains, a night guard shall be arranged until the responsible authorities take over;
4. Notify the Supervising Engineer who in turn will notify the responsible authorities immediately
(within 24 hours or less);
5. Responsible authorities are in charge of protecting and preserving the site before deciding on
subsequent appropriate procedures. This would require a preliminary evaluation of the findings to be
performed by archeologists. The significance and importance of the findings should be assessed
according to the various criteria relevant to cultural heritage; those include the aesthetic, historic,
scientific or research, social and economic values;
6. Decisions on how to handle the finding shall be taken by the responsible authorities. This could
include changes in the layout (such as when finding an irremovable remain of cultural or archeological
importance) conservation, preservation, restoration and salvage;
7. Implementation for the authority decision concerning the management of the finding shall be
communicated in writing by relevant local authorities; and
8. Construction works could resume only after permission is granted from the responsible local
authorities concerning safeguard of the physical cultural resource.
The provisions presented above should always be included in ESMPs as a precautionary measure
regardless of a site having known or unknown cultural heritage or physical cultural resource.
55 | P a g e
Pagina 56
ANNEX 3 - FORM FOR SUBMITTING SUGGESTIONS / COMMENTS
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION,
Project Management Unit for the Modernization of the School and University Network
„Safer, Inclusive and Sustainable Schools Project”
Bucharest, Sector 1, 12 Spiru Haret Street, 2nd floor
Feedback / petition* Form
School _________________________________ Locality__________________________________
* The completion of personal data is only necessary if you want this information to be treated as a Petition and to
receive a response, according to the regulations in force. In this case, it is necessary to submit your request,
complaint, referral or proposal through one of the following channels:
- In writing to the Project Management Unit (U.M.P.M.R.S.U.) of the Ministry of Education, str. Spiru Haret nr. 12,
Sector 1 Bucharest
- By the contact form on the U.M.P.M.R.S.U. website, - umpmrsu.ro
- by email at [email protected]
The information provided anonymously through this form will be taken into account and will be verified and used
for the purpose of improving the Project implementation activities and improving its impact.
Name and Surname
(Name of the entity)
Home County_______________________ Locality_________________________
(Headquarters) Street __________________________ No. ______ Bl. ________ Ap._____
Contact information: □ By mail: (indicate your mailing address only if it is different from your home
(Please tick the ways in address)
which you would like to County________________________ Locality______________________
be contacted) Str. __________________________ No. ______ Bl. __________ Ap._____
□ Phone _______________________________________
□ Email _________________________________________
□ Other (indicate) __________________________________
Brief content of the petition/information: (Please provide as full a description as possible of the issues
you wish to raise, what happened, when, who was involved, context, etc.)
Date: Signature:
____________________________ ________________________________
56 | P a g e